2Y 4.800 ▼5Y 4.900 ▼10Y 5.100 ▼30Y 5.460 =VIX 25.46 ▲MOVE 101.88 ▲DXY 103.69 ▲USD/JPY 159.54 ▲GOLD 3,823 ▼COPPER 5.98 ▼WTI 85.56 ▼BTC 64,723 ▼ETH 1,819 ▼S&P 7,341 ▼NDX 27,002 ▼MSTR 103.03 ▼
Rates · Liquidity · Scarcity · Credit · Power · 2026-11-17

The Breakeven Paid for the Hurdle. Crude Paid for the Breakeven.

A scarcity asset pays no coupon, so the whole of its valuation is the rate it is discounted at. That rate is the real yield: the return on a government bond once the market's expected inflation is stripped out. It has two legs, the cash yield and the inflation compensation the market charges, and the real rate is the first minus the second. Over the week those two legs moved in opposite directions by a wide margin - the cash 10yr up 3.1 basis points, the inflation leg down 10.0 - and the difference between them rose 13.1. The hurdle for every no-coupon asset is now 2.783%, the highest this column has carried since 20 October, and the leg that paid for it was the one nobody watches. Underneath it, the marks split three ways: the metals refused the move, crude paid for it, and the digital leg gave back rank. Ahead: why a falling inflation leg raises a real yield, the 5 consecutive closes that got the breakeven to 2.20, and the 4.1x gap between a common and its preferred.

The hurdle rose 13.1 basis points and the inflation leg paid 10.0 of them

The 10yr real yield is 2.783% - the 10yr cash note at 4.983% less inflation compensation of 2.20% (breakeven as of 10 Nov).

The prior session priced the same arithmetic at 2.644% - a 4.864% nominal (9 Nov) less a 2.22% breakeven (9 Nov). In the session the nominal rose 11.9 basis points and the breakeven fell 2.0, so the hurdle is 13.9 basis points higher.

A week ago it read 2.652% - a 4.952% nominal (3 Nov) less a 2.30% breakeven (3 Nov). Over the 5 sessions the nominal rose 3.1 basis points and the breakeven fell 10.0. The hurdle is 13.1 basis points higher, and the inflation leg supplied more than all of it.

That is the mechanism worth holding on to. The real rate is not a price the market sets; it is the residue of two, and the two moved in opposite directions this week. A cash yield that barely moved against an inflation compensation that fell hard produces the same real yield as a violent selloff in the long bond - but it is not the same event, and the marks underneath it did not treat it as one.

the hurdle decomposed: 10yr nominal = real + breakeven, per cent0123453 Nov2.6522.30nominal 4.9529 Nov2.6442.22nominal 4.86410 Nov2.7832.20nominal 4.983index print: real yield is the cash 10yr less the FRED breakeven on the same date, not a single reported value

The breakeven printed 2.20, a level it has closed at or below four times this year

The 10yr breakeven is 2.20% (10 Nov), from 2.30% (3 Nov). The path in between was five consecutive lower closes: 2.26% (4 Nov), 2.24% (5 Nov), 2.23% (6 Nov), 2.22% (9 Nov).

It has closed at or below 2.20% four times this year: 2.18% on 24 June, then 2.20% on 26 June, 28 July and 10 November.

The TIPS 10yr real series itself last printed 2.66% (9 Nov), a full session behind the cash marks. The computed real yield at 2.783% is the highest reading this column has carried since 20 October, when the same arithmetic gave 2.786%.

An inflation compensation that falls 10 basis points in five sessions is the market charging less for the inflation it expects over the next decade. It is not a growth story and it is not a policy story on its own. It is the price of one specific insurance falling, and that has a consequence for everything downstream that uses the real rate as a discount rate.

The front end repriced on its own: 2Y +12, 10Y +3

The 2yr is 4.73%, up 17 basis points in the session from 4.56% and 12 higher over the 5 sessions. The 10yr is 4.98%, up 10 in the session and 3 on the week. The 30yr is 5.35%, up 9 and 3.

The 2s10s on cash marks is 25.3 basis points, from 30.4 yesterday and 34.2 a week ago - the narrowest on cash marks since 22 September, when it printed 20.3. On the par curve the spread is 32.0 basis points (9 Nov close): 2yr 4.56%, 10yr 4.88%, 30yr 5.26%.

Two repricings are running at once and they are not the same trade. The front end is marking up the near-term policy path: 3-month 4.30% from 4.24%, 2yr up 17 in a session. The long end's inflation leg is marking down its own inflation expectation. Both push the real yield higher, and the curve absorbs the difference by flattening from both ends.

A curve that flattens because the front end rises is a policy repricing. A curve that flattens because the back end's inflation leg falls is an inflation repricing. This one is both, which is why the real yield moved so much further than the cash 10yr.

Gold lost $6.60 and added 1.5 rank points

Gold is 4,067.00, +36.80 in the session and -6.60 on the week, -0.16%. Percentile rank 62.8, from 61.3 a week ago.

Silver is 52.930, +1.829 in the session and +0.81 on the week, +1.55%. Rank 33.2, from 31.2.

A 13.1 basis point rise in the discount rate applied to an asset with no coupon should mark it down. Gold gave back six dollars and sixty cents, a sixth of one per cent, and improved its position in its own three-year distribution.

Silver is the only leg in the complex that is up on price over the week, and it is up 1.55% against a hurdle that rose 13 basis points. The monetary metals refused the rate move, and they refused it together, which is a stronger signal than either one alone.

Crude gave back 15.9 rank points and paid for the breakeven

West Texas crude is 86.59, +0.55 in the session and -1.47 on the week, -1.67%. Rank 52.8, from 68.7.

Brent is 92.50, +1.01 in the session and -2.12 on the week, -2.24%. Rank 41.6, from 55.7.

Crude sits directly upstream of the 10yr breakeven. The 14 rank points Brent gave back and the 10 basis points the breakeven gave back are the same trade read at two points in the chain: the market marked down the front of the energy curve, and the decade-long inflation compensation it prices came down with it.

Which puts the causal order the other way round from a rate selloff. The hurdle did not rise and then mark crude down. Crude marked down, the breakeven followed, and the real yield rose as the residue. That is the whole mechanism in one week and it is why the metals did not follow crude down.

Copper gave back 2.0 rank points and the ratio held

Copper is 6.3235, +0.104 in the session and -0.0765 on the week, -1.20%. Rank 84.8, from 86.8.

The copper/gold ratio is 0.00156, against 0.00159 a week ago. That ratio is the growth leg inside the composite, and the copper z-score of 1.509 is still the highest in the scarcity block.

Copper is the one industrial leg that did not break price. Down 1.20% on the week and 2.0 rank points is a give-back at the top of a narrow distribution, not a break: the price is 6.3235 against 6.3505 five sessions ago and the range it sits in is compressed.

Last Wednesday's column set rank 95 as the level copper had to hold for a physical-led read to stand, and it closed this week at 84.8. The read has now failed for two consecutive weeks, and the metal has not broken price either time. Rank loss without a price break is a distribution narrowing, not a demand event.

Bitcoin fell 2.62% and ether sits in the bottom fifth

Bitcoin is 73,525.74, -1,697.41 in the session and -1,981.55 on the week, -2.62%. Rank 42.8, from 47.6. The 30-day trend is -9.78%.

Ether is 2,053.40, -78.10 in the session and -168.90 on the week, -7.60%. Rank 17.7, from 24.4 - the bottom fifth of its three-year range.

A claim with no cash flow is worth the present value of a future price, and the rate that price is discounted at rose 13.1 basis points this week. Bitcoin fell 2.62%. That is not a repricing against the hurdle; it is a leg that gave back rank in an orderly way while the metals held.

The split inside the complex is now clean and it is not the split this column expected. The monetary metals held against a rising real yield. The monetary digital leg did not. Crude, which caused the breakeven move, took the largest rank hit. Delivery bottlenecks explain none of the three.

The coupon held; the common lost 10.7%

The Strategy common is 121.07, -4.52 in the session and -14.56 on the week, -10.74%. Rank 17.7, from 21.1.

STRC is 99.89, -0.03 in the session and +0.2201 on the week, rank 99.9 - the top of its range for the second week running. STRF is 102.44, -0.57 in the session and +0.39 on the week, rank 74.5. STRK is 67.26, -0.14 and -0.44, rank 27.9.

One issuer, four claims. The common fell 10.74% on a week in which the underlying coin fell 2.62% - 4.1 times the move - while the fixed-claim preferred added 0.22% and held the 99.9th percentile.

That is duration, not sentiment. The common is a perpetual option on the coin and its value is the convexity of a claim on a future price; the preferred is a fixed cash claim and its duration is short against it. At a real yield of 2.783% and rising, the option loses and the coupon holds. The ranking did not need a fall in the asset to show up two weeks ago. This week it got one and the gap widened to 10.7% against 0.2%.

Scarcity printed a file high; the composite crossed back to NEUTRAL

Scarcity is +1.065, the highest reading in the snapshot file, which starts on 10 September. It was +0.975 yesterday and +0.945 a week ago.

The composite headline is +0.336, regime NEUTRAL, on 5/5 sub-indices. Yesterday's frozen snapshot read +0.373 and the day before +0.496. The 0.35 threshold is what flipped the label; this is the first NEUTRAL print since 22 October, when it read +0.330.

Rates & Policy is +0.848, from +0.662. Credit & Stress is +0.420, from +0.457. Growth & Inflation is -0.237, from +0.117. Liquidity is -0.414, from -0.347 - the deepest negative in the block.

The average and its largest component are pointing opposite ways. Scarcity's rise was more than absorbed by Growth & Inflation falling 0.354 and Liquidity deepening. Four sub-indices pulled the headline under the threshold while the fifth printed a three-month high. On a positive-is-tightening scale, the composite is saying the pressure is no longer broad, and the theme of the day is saying where it concentrated.

Liquidity's inputs: reserve balances $2,930.1bn (as of 4 Nov), up $36.3bn from $2,893.8bn (as of 28 Oct); reverse repo take-up $0.15bn (as of 10 Nov). Growth & Inflation's: jobless claims 189k (week ended 31 Oct), continuing claims 1,718k (week ended 24 Oct). Credit's: HY OAS 3.34% (as of 9 Nov) against 3.43% (as of 2 Nov), IG OAS 0.91% (as of 9 Nov) against 0.94% (as of 2 Nov).

Equities: S&P 500 7,520.93, -47.99 on the week, rank 91.3; Nasdaq 100 27,740.79, -439.46. Long bonds: TLT 80.88, -0.23. VIX 19.46, -1.37 on the week, rank 18.8; MOVE 92.43, +6.45 in the session and -7.54 on the week.

What would confirm it, and what would break it

Confirmation is the breakeven holding at or below 2.25% while crude stays under rank 55 and gold holds above 62. That would say the inflation leg is being repriced and the marks are absorbing it, which is what this week's dispersion already shows.

The first invalidation is the breakeven back through 2.30% with the cash 10yr unchanged. The hurdle would fall to roughly 2.68% and gold's rank advance would read as a rate effect rather than a refusal of one. The distinction matters because a refusal is information and a rate effect is arithmetic.

The second is the front end. If the 2yr keeps rising while the breakeven keeps falling, the real yield keeps climbing without the long cash yield moving at all, and this becomes a policy repricing from which the metals are not insulated. Gold holding rank against falling inflation compensation is a different claim from gold holding rank against a tightening path.

The third is the monetary digital leg. Bitcoin is at rank 42.8 with a 30-day trend of -9.78%, and the capital structure underneath it is already stretched: the common at 17.7 against a preferred at 99.9. A bitcoin break below rank 40 with the 30-day trend through -12% would leave the coupon as the only claim in the structure with a bid, and that is a flight to duration rather than a scarcity bid.

Notes

1. UST cash marks, 10 November close: 2yr 4.73%, 5yr 4.81%, 7yr 4.89%, 10yr 4.98%, 20yr 5.39%, 30yr 5.35%; 3-month bill 4.30%. Source: US Treasury cash marks.

2. Treasury par curve, 9 November close: 2yr 4.56%, 3yr 4.58%, 5yr 4.67%, 7yr 4.76%, 10yr 4.88%, 20yr 5.29%, 30yr 5.26%; 2s10s 32.0 basis points. Source: US Treasury daily par yield curve.

3. Real yield computed as the 10yr nominal less the FRED 10yr breakeven, each leg dated: 2.783% on a 4.983% nominal (10 Nov) less a 2.20% breakeven (10 Nov); 2.644% on 4.864% (9 Nov) less 2.22% (9 Nov); 2.652% on 4.952% (3 Nov) less 2.30% (3 Nov). The TIPS 10yr real series itself last printed 2.66% (9 Nov). Sources: US Treasury cash marks; FRED T10YIE, DFII10.

4. Gold $4,067.00 (11 Nov), +36.80 in the session, -6.60 on 5 sessions, rank 62.8 against 61.3; silver $52.930, +1.829, +0.81, rank 33.2 against 31.2. Source: exchange closes.

5. Copper $6.3235/lb (11 Nov), +0.104 in the session, -0.0765 on 5 sessions, rank 84.8 against 86.8; copper/gold 0.00156 against 0.00159. Source: COMEX front-month close.

6. WTI $86.59 (11 Nov), +0.55 in the session, -1.47 on 5 sessions, rank 52.8 against 68.7; Brent $92.50, +1.01, -2.12, rank 41.6 against 55.7. Source: NYMEX and ICE front-month closes.

7. Bitcoin $73,525.74 (11 Nov), -1,697.41 in the session, -1,981.55 on 5 sessions, rank 42.8 against 47.6; -9.78% over 30 days, -2.62% over 5 sessions. Ether $2,053.40, -78.10, -168.90, rank 17.7 against 24.4; -7.60% over 5 sessions. Source: spot closes.

8. Dollar index 102.354 (11 Nov), +0.124 in the session, +0.772 on 5 sessions, rank 44.1 against 38.0. Source: ICE DXY.

9. Strategy common $121.07 (10 Nov), -4.52 in the session, -14.56 on 5 sessions, rank 17.7 against 21.1; STRC 99.89 (-0.03, +0.2201, rank 99.9 against 99.9); STRF 102.44 (-0.57, +0.39, rank 74.5 against 73.5); STRK 67.26 (-0.14, -0.44, rank 27.9 against 28.6). Source: exchange closes.

10. VIX 19.46 (10 Nov), -0.46 in the session, -1.37 on 5 sessions, rank 18.8; MOVE 92.43, +6.45, -7.54, rank 43.6. S&P 500 7,520.93, -29.01 in the session, -47.99 on 5 sessions, rank 91.3; Nasdaq 100 27,740.79, -166.84, -439.46; TLT 80.88, -1.08, -0.23.

11. HY OAS 3.34% (9 Nov), IG OAS 0.91% (9 Nov). Reserve balances $2,930.1bn (week ended 4 Nov). Reverse repo $0.15bn (10 Nov). Jobless claims 189k (week ended 31 Oct); continuing claims 1,718k (week ended 24 Oct). Core CPI is not carried in this snapshot and no CPI line is quoted. Sources: FRED BAMLH0A0HYM2, BAMLC0A0CM, WRESBAL, RRPONTSYD, ICSA, CCSA.

12. Composite headline +0.336, NEUTRAL, 5/5 sub-indices; Scarcity +1.065, Rates & Policy +0.848, Credit & Stress +0.420, Growth & Inflation -0.237, Liquidity -0.414. Positive is tightening pressure. Source: MacroTape composite.

13. Breakeven closes this year at or below 2.20%: 2.18% (24 Jun), 2.20% (26 Jun), 2.20% (28 Jul), 2.20% (10 Nov). Source: FRED T10YIE.

TENORLEVEL1D ΔZ (3Y)RANGE %ILE
2Y4.800-0.030+1.7387
5Y4.900-0.030+2.3890
10Y5.100-0.020+2.6389
30Y5.4600.000+2.1988
CALL & INVALIDATION
CallThe inflation leg paid for the hurdle. The 10yr real yield is 2.783%, 13.9 basis points higher in the session and 13.1 higher than a week ago, and the week's rise came entirely from the breakeven: the cash 10yr added 3.1 basis points while inflation compensation fell 10.0 to 2.20%, a level it has closed at or below four times this year. The front end repriced separately - 2yr 4.73% from 4.56%, +17 in the session - and the cash 2s10s flattened to 25.3 basis points, the narrowest since 22 September. Underneath a hurdle that rose 13 basis points, the marks split three ways: gold lost $6.60 and added 1.5 rank points to 62.8, silver rose 1.55% and added 2.0 to 33.2, crude gave back 15.9 rank points on WTI and 14.1 on Brent, and bitcoin fell 2.62% to rank 42.8. Scarcity printed +1.065, the highest in the file, while the composite fell under the 0.35 threshold to +0.336, NEUTRAL, on Growth & Inflation at -0.237 and Liquidity at -0.414. The expression is the metals' rank against a hurdle they refused, with the coupon-bearing preferred at 99.9 against a common at 17.7.
Evidence10yr real yield 2.783% on a 4.983% nominal less a 2.20% breakeven (10 Nov); 2.644% the prior session; 2.652% a week ago. 2yr 4.73% (+17 session, +12 week), 10yr 4.98% (+10, +3), 30yr 5.35% (+9, +3), 3-month 4.30%; cash 2s10s 25.3bp from 30.4 and 34.2, narrowest since 20.3 on 22 Sep; par 2yr 4.56%, 10yr 4.88%, 30yr 5.26%, 2s10s 32.0bp (9 Nov). Breakeven 2.20% (10 Nov) from 2.30% (3 Nov) over five consecutive lower closes. Gold $4,067.00, +36.80 session, -6.60 week, rank 62.8 from 61.3. Silver $52.930, +1.829, +0.81, rank 33.2 from 31.2. Copper $6.3235, +0.104, -0.0765, rank 84.8 from 86.8; copper/gold 0.00156 against 0.00159. WTI $86.59, +0.55, -1.47, rank 52.8 from 68.7; Brent $92.50, +1.01, -2.12, rank 41.6 from 55.7. Bitcoin $73,525.74, -1,697.41, -1,981.55, rank 42.8 from 47.6, -9.78% over 30 days; ether $2,053.40, -78.10, -168.90, rank 17.7 from 24.4. Dollar index 102.354, +0.772 on the week, rank 44.1. MSTR $121.07 (-14.56 on the week, rank 17.7); STRC 99.89 (+0.2201, rank 99.9); STRF 102.44 (+0.39, rank 74.5); STRK 67.26 (-0.44, rank 27.9). SPX 7,520.93 (-47.99); NDX 27,740.79 (-439.46); TLT 80.88 (-0.23); VIX 19.46 (rank 18.8); MOVE 92.43. HY OAS 3.34% (9 Nov); IG OAS 0.91% (9 Nov); reserves $2,930.1bn (4 Nov); RRP $0.15bn (10 Nov); claims 189k (week ended 31 Oct); continuing claims 1,718k (week ended 24 Oct). Composite +0.336, NEUTRAL, 5/5 sub-indices, Scarcity dominant at +1.065. Figures and sources: notes 1-13.
InvalidationThe breakeven back through 2.30% with the cash 10yr unchanged, which puts the hurdle at 2.68% and makes gold's rank advance a rate effect rather than a refusal of one. Or the front end: the 2yr rising while the breakeven falls, so the real yield climbs with no move in the long cash yield and the metals are no longer insulated. Or the monetary digital leg: bitcoin under rank 40 with the 30-day trend through -12%, which would leave the coupon as the only claim in the structure with a bid.
Levels2Y 4.56 / 10Y 4.88 / 30Y 5.26 / 2s10s 32
DISCLOSURE — NOT INVESTMENT ADVICE
NoticeMacroTape publishes macroeconomic analysis and market commentary for information and education only. Nothing published here is financial, investment, legal or tax advice, or a personal recommendation, and no author is a registered investment adviser. Calls, Levels and invalidation points are analytical views about how a market mechanism works, not instructions to trade. Readers act on their own responsibility and carry their own losses.